The Recruiting Roadmap

The Recruiting Roadmap

Nobody’s going to tell you the truth (and here’s why)

How to identify the blind spots before your college coaches do it for you in August

Alan Good's avatar
Alan Good
Mar 26, 2026
∙ Paid

You committed in January.

By March, something changed. Not all at once - just a slow drift.

You used to be first to practice. Now you’re rolling in right as it starts, sometimes a few minutes late.

You used to demand more from teammates when drills got sloppy. Now you let it slide. Everyone’s tired. It’s just club practice.

You used to ask your coach for extra feedback after training. Now you nod along, say “sounds good,” and head home.

The excuses come easy:

“I don’t get challenged here anymore.”

“I’m sick of hearing the same thing from the same coaches.”

“The younger players don’t know what they’re doing.”

Your club coach has seen this pattern before. The U19 group is the hardest to coach every year - not because they lack talent, but because the players who should be setting a standard of excellence instead set a standard of apathy and complaining.

You’re coasting. And nobody’s calling you out on it.

That’s the problem.

The incentive misalignment nobody talks about

After you commit, the system stops rewarding people for telling you the truth.

Your club coach sees the drop in intensity. She notices you’re coasting. But she doesn’t want to risk losing you to another club before you graduate. The placement looks good on the club owner’s resume. Why create conflict by demanding more when you don’t have long left anyway?

Your parents want to enjoy this moment. They’ve spent years stressed about recruiting. Now that it’s done, they don’t want to be the ones bringing up problems. When they see you skipping optional training or half-assing drills, they convince themselves it’s fine. You’ve earned a break.

Your high school coach needs you to win games. He’s not going to bench you for lack of effort when you’re still the best player on the field. Rebuilding your habits or questioning your commitment creates short-term performance drops he can’t afford.

Even your future college coaches have limited incentive or ability to push you hard right now. They can’t work with you directly yet. You’re not their problem until August of your freshman year.

You’re the main person who can benefit from your continued development. But you’re the least equipped to evaluate yourself objectively.

So the intensity drops. The standards slip. And everyone lets it happen.

The exercise that surfaces real weaknesses

Here’s what works.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Alan Good · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture